For a few years now, the notion of giftedness has become very popular in Quebec. Indeed, it is not uncommon for psychologists and neuropsychologists to receive requests for assessments from parents who are wondering about a possible giftedness. But what does it actually mean?
Giftedness is the presence, in a person, of a "gift" or talent greater than that of the general population. However, this notion is very broad. Someone can be gifted in sports, music, or school, for example. On the other hand, a child with a gift for music does not necessarily have a gift or particularly advanced abilities in other areas of their development. This is why the term more frequently used by neuropsychologists is "high intellectual potential." Indeed, the neuropsychological assessment serves, among other things, to evaluate the child's intellectual potential. However, neuropsychologists do not have the necessary expertise to rule on children's musical, sporting, or artistic gifts!
Various definitions of "high intellectual potential" (HPI) have been put forward. It is important to know that "giftedness" or "high intellectual potential" are not listed in the most recognized classifications of mental disorders (such as the DSM-5 or ICD-11): despite popular belief, giftedness is not a diagnosis. Giftedness is therefore an identification, and first and foremost a social construct, which evolves, as we compare the abilities of one child to another. But a child who, following an assessment, is not identified as having an HPI can very certainly be brilliant, talented, and very sensitive to others. The results of a cognitive or neuropsychological assessment, even if not conclusive in this regard, do not take anything away from the child!
What are some signs of HPI?
- An excellent memory
- A rich and varied vocabulary
- Exceptional logical reasoning abilities
- A strong thirst for learning, a child who asks a lot of questions, showing interest in a variety of subjects
Now, the mere presence of an excellent memory and boundless curiosity is not enough to identify a child as having an HPI. HPI is identified when a child presents an intellectual potential (IQ) at a very high level. The child then has excellent verbal and non-verbal reasoning abilities. Thus, about 2% of the population would have an HPI, although some presentations, such as twice exceptionality, complicate this statistic.
Although sensory peculiarities and affective hypersensitivity are sometimes present, these peculiarities are not sufficient to suspect an HPI.
What is "twice exceptionality"?
"Twice exceptionality" (2E), is the presence of a high intellectual potential (HPI) and a disorder or disability, although the majority of research on the subject is related to 3 profiles of twice exceptionality.
HPI and ADHD
This is probably the most well-known type of twice exceptionality and the most frequently suspected, particularly for children who are bored in class and can become disruptive. Although it is only a very small proportion of the population that presents such a twice exceptionality, these children do present a particular profile. Often, they are children with advanced reasoning and vocabulary, but who have difficulty maintaining their attention on the task. Some of these young people also tend to give up as soon as they encounter the slightest difficulty, as they are not used to having to make sustained efforts in the face of challenges. They have lots of brilliant ideas and are highly creative, but do not always manage to complete the tasks they start.
HPI and Learning Disorder
Children with this type of profile can easily go unnoticed. Indeed, they demonstrate strong reasoning skills, and, despite the presence of a learning disorder, manage to do well in school, even though those around them often feel that they are not reaching their full potential. Indeed, they may be slower at reading, but manage to answer text comprehension questions in a way comparable to their peers because they use their excellent reasoning skills to "fill in the gaps" of the words they were not able to read correctly.
HPI and Autism Spectrum Disorder
This combination is the one people often think of when the syndrome formerly called Asperger's is mentioned (although this is not entirely accurate), characters such as "Rain Man" or even Sheldon in "The Big Bang Theory." Here, the person has a high intellectual potential as well as several peculiarities suggesting an Autism Spectrum Disorder. Here, the line is sometimes thin between the particular interest of the child who has an ASD and the one who has "only an HPI." For example, a child who knows all kinds of dinosaurs may have an ASD and/or an HPI, and it is only by looking at the child's complete profile that we can really determine "what is what" in their peculiarities. These children also tend to have major tantrums, related to a sense of injustice, misunderstanding, or even related to their social skills, which are often out of sync with their intellectual potential.
Although less frequently observed, we can also talk about "multiple exceptionality" when a child presents a high potential accompanied by more than one diagnosis. For example, we can see children with an HPI as well as ADHD and a Specific Learning Disorder. Or even a child with an HPI, ADHD, ASD, as well as difficulties with motor coordination.
In the presence of twice or multiple exceptionality, it is sometimes possible to observe a phenomenon called "masking," where the high potential is less easily observed due to the child's difficulties at different levels. The neuropsychological assessment then serves to draw a complete picture of the individual in order to understand both their strengths and weaknesses and thus be able to put in place adaptations that will be specific to the strengths and weaknesses of each child.
"Simple" high potential
In cases of "simple" high potential, the child generally functions well, but may need additional stimulation at school, for example with academic acceleration (e.g., skipping a grade) or personal projects aimed at enrichment. However, in children with twice exceptionality, support tailored to the difficulties may be necessary and varied (psychologist for anxiety, psychoeducator for emotion management, special education teacher for learning or organizational difficulties, occupational therapist for motor or sensory difficulties, etc.).
It is important to remember that giftedness, or high intellectual potential, is not a disorder, but rather a protective factor. HPI cannot be identified on the basis of personality traits (e.g., hypersensitivity or behavioural problems in class). However, when difficulties (academic, behavioural, or other) complicate life at school or at home, it is time to ask for help. It may then be relevant to start with an assessment, and then identify the child's real needs.
The website of the Association des Neuropsychologues du Québec is a good source of information and reference, as is the website of the Ordre des psychologues du Québec. Your child's school or doctor can also often provide you with references to professionals in your area.





