Cultivating a taste for the forbidden, why not?

Do you know the tale of Bluebeard? That bloodthirsty lord who gives the keys to his castle to his new, young wife, while forbidding her to open the room marked with an X? Driven by an unspeakable curiosity, she hurries to visit all the rooms of this fabulous estate. But, in her gentle hands, it’s the key to room X that burns her fingers. It’s forbidden. Yet, what could be more tempting, more obsessive than defying the forbidden.

It’s the same for our little ones who dare to defy our prohibitions, eyeing us from the corner of their eye. Beware, we’re not talking about room X here, but about those little prohibitions that make our parental vigilance coherent. We’re talking about… turn off the TV now… yeah, but I can’t find the button anymore (just to prolong the pleasure of this 4-year-old remote control pro)… don’t draw on the walls (to this future Riopelle, armed with a permanent Sharpie)… don’t eat Christmas chocolate without permission (to that brown-drooling mouth, pointing at a too-accessible tray)…

In François Gravel’s excellent novel, L’effet Summerhill, he sets forth this concept of the taste for the forbidden that needs to be reinstated in a social context where the fear of restricting outweighs the need to raise socially agreeable individuals, where the desire to do well can, on the contrary, harm the flourishing of our offspring. According to this novel, having family prohibitions allows, yes, to make the child creative (how to get around this rule), confident (I can do it and I’ll still be loved), perseverant (next time, I’ll succeed), daring (the risk is so worth the pleasure), and so on.

So, I insist, following new research that encourages children’s daring in public parks, and within the limited framework of our LITTLE prohibitions that ensure a healthy diet, a pleasant social attitude, and consistency in our family values, prohibitions at this level have their place, don’t they?